Journal paper review process queries:

 1.  How many days does it take for the whole review process of a conference and a journal?

A: For a conference, one has to check the website of the related conference to know the date of the final result. 

For a journal, it depends on the Publication, and a rough analysis based on previous experience is as follows:

Ex: TWC: 3 months,

      TCOM: 3-4 months,

      TIV:  1 month

      TVT: 3 months 

2. Acceptance rate of the paper under review: 

For the conference, the accept and reject ratio of any conference in the ideal case is  30:70

Case 1: Sometimes it may undergo "Unsubmit" status after under review status, especially due to the format, font size, line limit per page issue, and misprinted references. Hence, it is important to check the mail even after it the submitted successfully. Usually, one will be notified within a week of the submission regarding this kind of issue. 

Case 2: Once it is under review for more than a week, then we can expect the acceptance or "Major revision" or "Rejection" or "Rejection and resubmission." Acceptance in the first attempt is not an idle case. One can expect a "Major revision" with a probability based on the type of publication. 

Ex: 

1. Under "Rejection," one can resubmit.

2. Under "Major revision," one can address the comments and resubmit. Chances of acceptances = >50%.

3.  Under "Reject and resubmit," the chances of major revision = 50%.

4. Under "Minor revision," once the comments are addressed and submitted, the chances of acceptance = 100%.


3. What are the stages of review of a journal paper?

Under review: for 1.5 months

Awaiting Reviewers Scores: 1 month

Awaiting Editor Decision: 15 days




Special case:

1. Subconnected paper: 

Major revision submitted on Jan 11.

Editor decision status on Apr 8. 

Result: Apr 9



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NOMA-THz by Ding

 Treat the predefined beams as bandwidth. The coverage area has 4 users and NOMA-assisted using beam based resource allocation to each user 4 beams for 4 users. But when we add more users, then they will fit in the existing beams. example: new 5 users added. Now, we have 3 beams serving 2 users each and 1 beam serving 3 users.  BEAM ALLOCATION FOR THZ-NOMA AND MIMO-NOMA.  BEAMS ARE LOCATION RESTRICTED.  age of information: 
Read more

Steps to start work on LLM from scratch:

 1. Basic Programming skills on Python 2. Few basics of ML or Deep learning  3. Start with udemy free course:  https://www.udemy.com/course/langchain/ 4. Get paid subscription for Open AI :  https://openai.com/index/openai-api/ 5. Get Paid subscription for serapi:  https://serpapi.com/users/sign_in Note: Serapi is used for google search results. In courses, they says its a free api but when we use it in code, it wont work until and unless it is an paid version. One can explicitly define few values during tutorials to avoid paid subscriptions.  6. Get chatgpt 4 subscription:  https://chatgpt.com/auth/login?sso Note: For google search results till 2021, we can use chatgpt 4 instead of serapi. However, note that we can't get results for > 2021.  7. 
Read more